Get Catelyn's dagger from "Pretty Boy" Duncan.
My FATHER sent you? I'd have thought that old codger would have given up on me by now.
It wasn't really his fault I ran off, he just shouldn't have expected I'd be willing to live a boring life, reading over musty books and associating with grey-haired, stiff-backed, stuffy mages!
If you need my dagger, you'll have to get it back from "Pretty Boy" Duncan, one of the Bloodsail Buccaneers. Put something 'tween his shoulders and I'm sure he'll give it up.
I'd never been beat before, you know, <name>? Sure I'd been cut, can't get in a knife fight without that, but he just smacked me on the side of the head, blacked me out. When I came to my blade was gone.
As much as my nickname might indicate, I still need a knife to fight, and for me, it has to be that one.
You beat Duncan? I guess you aren't as wet behind the ears as you looked at first glance.
I suppose that also means I shouldn't challenge you to a fight any time soon!
Upon completion of this quest you will gain: